Published by admin on 08 Feb 2010
Why I Prefer Fingers By Chuck Adams
Why I Prefer Fingers
Fingers vs. Release Debate
By Chuck Adams
http://www.bowandarrowhunting.com/
The giant caribou I named “Old Stubby” was snoozing a long bow shot away amid a sea of red willow brush. The antlers of five smaller bedded bulls rose high above the bushes, but Stubby had laid his rack on its side. I could barely see the massive, heavily palmated right top with its long, blunt-tipped tines. The bull was sleeping now, but I had studied his entire rack earlier in the stalk. He was awesome…the largest mountain caribou I had ever seen.
Suddenly, a wolf howled up canyon. The strong-jawed predator was probably more than a mile away, but its booming voice made it sound close enough to attack. All six caribou were on their feet in an instant, moving toward me with their ankle-clicking, ground-gobbling gait.
I was crouched on my knees in skimpy cover, and I dropped my head to the ground as the first five ‘bou ambled past inside 25 yards. Stubby was in the rear, and I struck like a rattlesnake as he passed on the upwind side. I straightened at the waist, wrapped my fingers around the bowstring and drew my Hoyt ProStar compound in one fluid motion. I aimed and drilled the bull as his eyes rolled and he turned away in panic. The entire episode took no more than two seconds.
That big 1995 caribou has been the Pope & Young World Record ever since, eclipsing a former record that stood for 17 years. And like several other giant animals in quick-moving situations. I would never have bagged Old Stubby with a mechanical release.
I’ve been shooting fingers for 37 yards—mostly with a bowsight and string peep—and I prefer a finger release for serious hunting. One reason is shooting speed. A trigger device might be a bit more accurate in deliberate shooting situations, but not all hunting shots are slow and deliberate. It is one thing to drill a foam 3-D target or a whitetail from a tree, and quite another to crawl-and-shoot for caribou or twist-and-shoot for elk.
Don’t get me wrong. Like Randy Ulmer, Phil Phillips and other excellent release shooters I know, I recognize the benefits of a release aid. I’ve shot plenty of game with a release—whitetails from trees, waterhole antelope, African antelope from blinds, etc. A beginning archer with a release can achieve tighter target groups, with less effort, than an archer using a finger glove or tab. It’s simply easier to squeeze a trigger or press a button and hit the target. The best target scores on bull’s-eyes and 3-D animals are shot with release aids for the same reason.
But for serious bowhunting by those who care to practice hard, I believe the finger release yields an edge. Here are reasons why I rely on my fingers for really serious hunting.
Shooting Speed
For fluid, non-fumbling performance with a bow, I believe fingers are best. That’s why most bird shooters and bow fishermen prefer a tab or glove.
Most of the animals I stalk can be neatly drilled with a release. But 5 percent to 10 percent cannot. It is difficult to snap a release to the string, then draw, hold and aim with lightning speed. It is impossible to hike all day after mule deer, elk, caribou or maintain sheep with a release aid attached to the string and your wrist, so you sometimes have to fumble to take a quick shot. On some animals, fumbling simply isn’t fast enough.
In general, the largest and wisest game is also the most difficult to shoot. Such animals did not get big by being easy, so when you do get a shot, that shot will probably be fast. I have had the good fortune to shoot 11 official P&Y animals and five P&Y World Record animals, and I can tick off three World Records and a dozen other book critters that I would never have shot with a release.
Now please don’t assume I have not shot and practiced with a release aid. I use my old Scott Caliper on many tree-stand whitetail hunts, pronghorn ground-blind hunts, etc. In such controlled, deliberate shooting situations, a release aid is not a handicap. I can drill tacks with a mechanical release and a well-tuned bow, and my bull’s-eye groups certainly shrink. But heaven help me if I had had a release aid on Old Stubby, the World Record mountain caribou, or on my new 2000 World Record Montana elk. Both critters gave me the briefest shot imaginable from twisted ground-level body positions.
For occasional quick shots, on foot-hunted game, a finger release rules!
Shooting Silence
The hard jaws on a release aid will strum the bowstring like a guitar pick. A tied-in string loop helps dampen such noise, but adds to the “fumble factor” when you try to hook up fast.
By comparison, pliable fingers further cushioned by a shooting tab or glove tend to dampen bowstring noise during the shot. All else being equal—string and cable silencers in place, noise dampeners on limbs, and a flexible bow stabilizer up front—the finger-shot bow is noticeably quieter than the release-shot bow. This means less string-jumping by sound-sensitive creatures like whitetail deer.
If you don’t believe this, stand behind a tree and have a friend shoot the same bow and arrow past you with a hard-jaw release and fingers. The difference in decibel noise level will be dramatic.
I have lost count of the times release-shooting friends have scared animals with a wrist-swinging, clanking release aid. If release hardware impacts the bow, cable guard, arrow quiver, binocular or rangefinder, deer call, or any other hard object, the target animal will flee. Fingers with a soft tab or glove never create such noise.
Another noise problem with a release aid can be the type of arrow rest needed for good accuracy. So-called “launcher rests” with two prongs shoot well with a release because they cushion the up-and-down flexing of a release-launched arrow. But arrow fall-off is commonplace in game-shooting situations. If the wind blows or you cant your bow even a little bit, the arrow can fall off the rest with a dreadful clank.
And don’t think for a minute that “experts” are immune from this trouble. I’m in plenty of hunting camps each year, and I hear plenty of arrow fall-off stories. I’ve also watched dozens of 3-D tournaments, including the prestigious and action-packed Buckmasters Round. In one Buckmasters National Final a few years ago, three national release-aid champions let their arrows tall off the rest as they tried to aim at pop-up animal targets. All three managed to regroup and nail the mark, but no deer alive would have stood for such noisy nonsense!
By comparison, a finger shooter needs a more stable rest with a shelf and plate—a rest that tames the side bending (paradoxing) of a finger-released arrow. Finger rests like the flipper/plunger, springy, and Cavalier cradle an arrow solidly in place. An experienced finger archer also torques the bowstring as he draws, which presses the arrow securely against the rest. There is no way the arrow can fall off—even with high wind or a canted bow.
Simplicity and Dependability
When I go bowhunting, I’m sure my sting-drawing fingers won’t break. I’m also certain my fingers won’t jam up from grime, or freeze solid before I can shoot. And I know I won’t lose my fingers.
The same cannot be said for a mechanical release aid. Modern releases are reasonably dependable, but they are devices with moving parts. This means they can fail unexpectedly.
One release-using pal of mine watched the biggest pronghorn antelope he’d ever seen approach a waterhole 20 yards from his blind. He drew and aimed as the buck dropped its head to drink…and then nearly tore the release trigger off as he vainly tried to take his shot. The mechanism had jammed from dust and grit on the prairie, and the release was permanently locked to the bow-string. He still has nightmares about that monster walking away.
Another friend was on a super-expensive bowhunt for Rocky Mountain bighorn sheep. It was November, with temperatures dipping to minus 20 degrees. When he finally set up a 30-yard shot at a massive full-curl ram, his release refused to engage with the bowstring. The moving parts had gotten damp and then frozen solid—which completely ruined his hunt.
I’ve been in several camps where release aids broke or started pre-releasing at half-draw. One guy knocked out his front tooth as I watched after his metal release disengaged at half draw and slammed backward into his face.
In my experience, simple and dependable bowhunting gear works best. For serious hunting, I’ll take fingers every time!
Mechanical malfunctions aside, it’s fairly easy to lose a release. A smart release hunter carries two identical releases at all times in case one falls from a pocket or otherwise disappears. I’ve lost two finger tabs during my entire bowhunting life, and I shot an animal on each of those days (one caribou, one elk) with my bare fingers. Bow tune and broadhead accuracy was not greatly affected.
By comparison, try finger-shooting a release-aid bow. Tune, accuracy and a smooth shot go completely out the window.
Notes On Finger Accuracy
Release-aid advocates make a big deal of accuracy on targets and game. They tend to poo-poo the ability of bowhunters to finger-shoot well. But I’m here to tell you that finger-shooting can be deadly, even at 50 or 60 yards.
Finger shooting takes more practice because releasing with multiple fingers is tougher than simply tripping a trigger. But correct finger shooting can certainly produce consistent arrow flight.
In my experience, the best finger shooters approach “archer’s minute of angle” accuracy—1-inch arrow groups at 10 yards, 2-inch groups at 20 yards, 3-inch groups at 30 yards, 4-inch groups at 40 yards, and so on. The best release shooters can do even better, but what hunter needs better than 4-inch groups at 40 yards or 6-inch groups at 60 yards? Target shooters want even tighter groups, but we’re not in the woods to win tournaments. If you can hit a deer’s 9-inch vital chest every time, you shoot plenty well enough.
Here are some tips on getting the best hunting accuracy with your fingers.
First, shoot the right equipment. Compound bows less than 43 or 44 inches axle-to-axle are a handicap because severe bowstring angle at full draw pinches your fingers and prevents a smooth release. My favorite finger bows are the Reflex Caribou and Hoyt ProTec, both about 46 inches long.
Aggressive cams and high letoff both hurt finger-shooting accuracy. A mild wheel with letoff between 50 percent and 65 percent gives crisp, consistent accuracy with fingers.
I personally use multiple sight pins plus a peep with a finger bow. I anchor for three to five seconds as I aim, then release the string by relaxing my fingers and letting my string hand slide backward along my face. Every top finger shooter I know uses a tab—not a glove—because gloves develop grooves and hang up on the bowstring. Most good finger shooters draw with three fingers, then relax the top or bottom finger for a slicker two-finger release. Most place one finger above the arrow nock and two below.
Final Thoughts
A majority of bowhunters use mechanical release aids today, but I’m not sure this is best for hunting. Manufacturers and dealers push release aids and related accessories such as overdraw rests because they can sell you more gear and make more money. Most modern hunting bows are too short to finger-shoot anyway because short bows produce more raw arrow speed. Speed bows work fine with release aids, but pinch the heck out of fingers if you try the “old fashioned way. “ Very few finger compounds are now available, so bowhunters are being herded en masse toward release aids and short, fast bows.
But if you want maximum advantage on game, consider the finger-shooting alternative. You’ll shoot faster and quieter with less chance of something going wrong, and you’ll shoot very well if you practice with a tab, two-finger release and a reasonably long and forgiving bow.
Fingers work for me, and I rarely leave a big-game tag unfilled.
PART II
The Release Aid Is Better
By Randy Ulmer
Three-quarters of North America’s bowhunters (and the number is growing) aren’t wrong. Most bowhunters are far better off releasing the string with a mechanical release aid than with their fingers. I base my position on more than just the numbers. Believe me, I’ve tried everything. If fingers were the best way to release a bowstring I would have calluses like a rawhide on my fingertips. Instead, when I draw my bow on a big bull or buck I have an old, worn Fletchunter strapped around my wrist where it has been for the past 20 hunting seasons. I’ve put together five fundamental reasons why the release aid is, and always will be, the best way to reach your potential as a bowhunter.
Release Aids Are More Accurate
I took a lesson from noted target archer Frank Pearson about 15 years ago. It was early in my competitive career and I hung on every word Frank had to say. Near the end of the session I asked him to tell me the most profound thing he had learned about archery. I expected a dissertation on some mystical element of form but instead his answer was blunt and very simple: “Fingers suck!” Enough said.
Sure, there are highly skilled finger shooters who can hang with some of the best release-aid shooters at every local club, but this person is the exception, not the rule. Line everyone up and shoot scores. You’ll find that the average release shooter is more accurate than the average finger shooter.
A release aid is an emotionless machine; it doesn’t care how cold your fingers are, how big the buck is or even how much you have been practicing. It only cares that its trigger was pulled. Regardless of circumstance, it frees the string with amazing consistency—much better than can be attained with real live fingers. It is much easier for a release-aid shooter to pull the triger the same way every time than for a finger shooter to get two or three fingers to clear the string identically shot after shot. In archer, consistency is synonymous with accuracy.
Release Aids Help Eliminate Target Panic
Finger shooters get target panic just as readily as poorly schooled release-aid shooters, but unfortunately their cure seems more like psychiatric therapy than archery instruction. Beyond using a clicker, they have no mechanical solutions. Beating the dreaded malady when shooting fingers depends on the archer’s ability to control his emotion and nerves. Beating target panic with a release aid is all about selecting the right tool and technique. Using a lot of self-discipline, you follow the proper steps using a release aid designed for this purpose and, viola, the beast is dead (or at least hiding).
I know several bowhunters who released with fingers in the past but now shoot a release aid. These guys switched for only reason: A properly used release aid was the only way they were finally able to beat target panic. If you are having trouble keeping the pin floating near the spot you want to hit without watching it lurch about, try this. Just as you start to relax your fingers, you will be amazed at how much easier and more relaxing archery can become when you switch to a release aid and learn to shoot it correctly.
Release Aids Require Less Practice Time
It takes a lot of practice time to keep your fingers release functioning like a well-oiled machine whereas a release aid is already a well-oiled machine. If your busy lifestyle makes it tough to get to the range, you will find that a mechanical release will keep you in the bull’s-eye with a lot less practice.
Release Aids Make Tuning Easier
Consistency is a nice quality to find in a friend, but it is absolutely essential in your archery equipment and technique. A consistent release not only produces accuracy but also clean, controllable arrow flight. There is no greater step you can take toward achieving perfect bullet-hole delivery—shot after shot—than to use a mechanical release. Not only does the string leave more or less straight forward; the thrust of the string occurring right down the centerline of the arrow.
An arrow released with fingers goes through a series of oscillations called paradox. As the string leaves the fingers it moves to the side slightly and , of course, takes the nock of the arrow with it. Now the force of the string is directed at an angle to the arrow’s centerline causing the shaft to flex. It is critical when tuning a bow with fingers to get the perfect shaft stiffness so it will flex the proper amount to recover in time to clear both the rest and the riser as it speeds forward.
This entire dynamic situation is infinitely less complicated when a mechanical release is used. The string lines up with the centerline of the arrow to push it straight out of the bow. Not only is side-to-side oscillation of the string and arrow virtually eliminated, but also the archer has a lot more leeway in choosing arrows. Because arrow stiffness is rarely the cause of tuning problems for the release shooter, the shooter has the ability to consider a wider selection on shafts.
If the archer wants to shoot a heavy carbon shaft that is way too stiff for his draw weight he can do it without problems. He can also go in the other direction, selecting lightweight shafts that would be too flexible for a finger shooter using the same bow. When using a release aid, archers can move one level up (more flexible) on most shaft selection charts and as many levels down (stiffer) as they wish without introducing arrow flight problems. Try that when releasing the string with fingers! Let me rephrase that: Definitely don’t try that with fingers!
Release Aids Are Better When It’s Cold
You don’t have to worry about limbering up your release. Regardless of the temperature, it will be ready to dump the string when the trigger is squeezed. Fingers, on the other hand, get stiff as they get cold, making it less likely that they can be counted to produce a smooth release after several hours on a cold stand. Sure you can use hand muffs and a thin glove on your string hand, but in the end your fingers don’t stand a chance. When your body starts to feel the chill, it naturally restricts blood flow to the extremities. The fingers are the first to shut down. When that happens, the finger release becomes less predictable.
Cold temperatures, however, have little affect on the accuracy of a bowhunter using a mechanical release. As long as the bowhunter practices with heavy gloves prior to the hunt—so he’s used to the feel of several millimeters of Thinsulate between his finger and the trigger—his accuracy won’t be affected. Even fingers that are completely numb can still be commanded to curl.
Combating Negative Perceptions
Less reliable: Finger shooters love to tell release-aid shooters how unreliable their tools are. I’ve been hunting with a release for 20 years and my release aid had yet to cost me an animal. Sure, there are some questionable releases on the market that could be less reliable than others, but if you stick with tried-and -true designs made by leading manufacturers and practice until you are comfortable you won’t have a problem. I personally favor Carter releases for 3_D and target competition and my old Fletcher for hunting.
Takes too long to load: It may take slightly longer to load a release aid than to simply grab the string with your fingers, but when have you ever had to take a shot when you couldn’t spare a half-second? We’re not talking about jump-shooting pheasants here. Most bowhunting encounters are well rehearsed and well planned; in a word they are controlled. We generally know well in advance when a shot is likely to occur. It is rare indeed that an animal takes the hunter completely by surprise and then presents only a fleeting shot.
I participated in the speed rounds at ESPN’s Great Outdoor Games last summer using a release aid. In fact, all the top competitors were using release aids. If you think releases are so much slower when loading and shooting than fingers then why didn’t a finger shooter finish in the top ranks?
Something else to lose or forget: When I’m hunting, I carry an identical backup release aid in my daypack. If I should somehow drop my release while in a tree stand I will simply in the pack for the spare and pick the other one up on the way out. I make a habit of clicking my release to the bow just as soon as I take it off my wrist. In this way I never have to wonder where my release is: It is always either on my wrist or on my bow. Never lost.
Harder on your bowsting: There is no question that a releases jaws will wear your bowstring’s serving faster than three fingers if you don’t take appropriate steps to protect it. You will definitely have problems with factory serving, so after you break in your string you need to reserve it with a high quality serving material. BCY’s new spectra Halo serving is the strongest on the market and what I recommend. Serve it tight. I always double serve my bowstings to ensure that I never have to worry about serving slippage. A string-nocking loop will also help preserve serving life. The loop will eventually wear out and need replacing, but the serving will be protected.
I have yet to introduce a friend to the mechanical release who, after giving it an honest try, ever went back to shooting with fingers. If you aren’t already using a release aid you owe it to yourself in give it a try. After a couple of weeks of practice you will find the experience both comfortable and wholly enjoyable. Next you will begin to shoot better than you ever thought possible and your confidence will soar. You’d better buy a deep freezer, cause you’re gonna fill it this fall.












































































